Music stuff feedback
So last night I went back to composing for the first time in over 2 years, and even though I lack a lot of confidence in my writing, I apparently decided it was a good idea to jump straight back into it with a polyphonic canon. Noob Noob Noob 

Obviously I am not my best critique, but this is just a WIP and nothing has been polished yet. I've worked on it for about 2 or 3 hours in two sittings now, and I basically just go with the flow without thinking back. Opinions so far ?
If you're reading this, it means I have not made a cool signature yet and you should be proud of yourself.
The Following 9 Users Say Thank You to TRUC For This Useful Post:
  • Ashley766, Dangevin, Fresh Cookies, gemj, Hyperacticpro, JEEJAYEM, Lego-man945, Lunanova, Titanium
The Following 1 User Says Thank You to Hyperacticpro For This Useful Post:
  • TRUC
What a gorgeous piece! Well done @TRUC!!

You should consider writing a song for PR2... 👀

I post about the latest site updates on the Dev Log. If you have suggestions, feel free to post them here.
@Eternal and I pay for this site out of our own savings. Please donate to help keep Jiggmin's Village free for all.
The Following 1 User Says Thank You to bls1999 For This Useful Post:
  • TRUC
That's incredible!!! Eek Big Grin
"Do today what others won't, so tomorrow you can do what others can't" 💡 -Jerry Rice
The Following 1 User Says Thank You to Ashley766 For This Useful Post:
  • TRUC
Loving it bro
The Following 1 User Says Thank You to Kzza For This Useful Post:
  • TRUC
Nice! Definitely could be played in a Ye Old Castle Town in a video game. I haven't heard any of your other stuff so I don't have further reference but: Do you usually stick to 1 phrase for your compositions? It might make things feel fresh to throw in a B section. But it would probably be weird to have 1 B section amongst many A's so you'd have to play around with having a couple in there I'd imagine.

How do you feel about this transition: 
If your bass is playing 1...2...4...3.2. (1 is high) then after doing that phrase having 3major, 3minor, 1major, 2major (maybe twice?)
It sounds like a good way to end the song too, has like a resolving sign of relief feeling.

I also am not classically trained nor do I write classical music so... take my words with like 4 grains of salt  Embarrassed

EDIT: Also IDK what a polyphonic canon is so this suggestion might be against those rulesssssssss
The Following 1 User Says Thank You to Lunanova For This Useful Post:
  • TRUC

Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)